Law & Order

VIDEO: DA Says Fatal Shooting Of Omaha Rioter Was Self-Defense

By

The Omaha district attorney said Monday that Jake Gardner was justified in using lethal force against James Scurlock.

Omaha, NE – The district attorney announced no charges would be filed against an Omaha bar owner who used justified deadly force when he shot a 22-year-old protester named James Scurlock in self-defense in front of his business May 30 (video below).

Surveillance videos showed that at about 10:15 p.m. on May 30, less than an hour before the fatal incident, Scurlock and a friend vandalized the RDG Planning and Design architectural firm in the former Omaha Chamber of Commerce building located on the corner of 12th and Harney, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

Videos obtained by the Omaha World-Herald showed Scurlock entered the building through a smashed window, picked up an office chair, and threw it into two computer monitors.

Then he tore a phone from a desk and hurled it at the wall where it stuck, hanging out of the broken drywall.

The video showed that the other rioter with Scurlock in the video smashed another computer monitor, and then Scurlock pulled a mask back over his face and both men left the destroyed business, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

Watch the incident unfold in the video below. WARNING – Graphic Content and Obscene Language:

Just down the street, Jake Gardner, the owner of bars The Hive and The Gatsby which are located next door to each other, was inside his business with his father, David Gardner and one of the bouncers who worked at the bars, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Gardner, who served as a U.S. Marine in Haiti and Iraq, had posted on Facebook about having to protect his business.

“Just when you think, ‘what else could 2020 throw at me?’ Then you have to pull 48 hours of military style firewatch,” he posted.

At about 10:55 p.m., rioters began breaking the windows on other nearby businesses, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Someone threw rocks and an Old Market signpost through the windows of The Hive.

Gardner and his father both told police that when the windows suddenly shattered, they thought somebody was shooting at them, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Both Jake and David Gardner ran outside and confronted a group of people in front of the bar, one of whom was Spurlock.

David Gardner got into a shoving match with somebody else in the group, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

A law enforcement official said that at 10:56 p.m., the video showed the same rioter featured in the video with Spurlock smashing computer monitors at the architecture firm pushed David Gardner to the ground.

Douglas County Attorney Don Kleine said Jake Gardner rushed over to his fallen father and asked what happened, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

Then the video showed Jake Gardner backing up at 10:57 p.m. as Scurlock and another man approached him.

Jake Gardner lifted his shirt in the video to show he had a gun at his waist, then he pulled the pistol out and held it down at his side, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

“That (expletive) got a gun,” someone in Scurlock’s group said in the video and then waved at the bar owner, as if to shoo him away. “It’s not worth it (expletive) you stu–.”

Seconds later, a woman – later identified as Alayna Melendez of Omaha – tackled Jake Gardner from behind, landing him on his back in a puddle in the middle of Harney Street, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

At 10:58 p.m., the video showed Jake Gardner fired two warning shots into the air and then attempted to get up from the ground.

The video showed that’s when Scurlock jumped on Gardner from behind and put him in what authorities have called both a “headlock” and a “chokehold,” the Omaha World-Herald reported.

“Get off me, get off me,” Jake Gardner screamed in the video, according to the district attorney.

Scurlock had Gardner’s right arm pinned so the military veteran switched the gun to his left hand.

Then he fired over his shoulder and shot his attacker in the neck-shoulder area, killing him, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

The entire struggle lasted 20 seconds and left Spurlock dead.

Police took Jake Gardner into custody and he was questioned with his attorneys present before being released late on Sunday night, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

The district attorney said he and his chief deputy, Brenda Beadle, reviewed the videos and witness statements for 12 hours “with all of the homicide detectives.”

“There was a consensus that the actions of the shooter were justified,” Kleine said. “We certainly wish that none of this would have happened. It’s a senseless death.”

He said no one in the room felt Jake Gardner should face charges, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Nebraska law says that a person may use justifiable deadly force to protect themselves or others, but not property.

Kleine and Omaha Police Chief Todd Schmaderer said they had methodically broken down five videos of the incident, but said they would be happy to review any other video to look for different angles, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

But the district attorney and the police chief told reporters at the press conference to announce their decision that they felt the initial five videos had given them solid view of the incident.

Kleine, who has been a prosecutor for 30 years, said he didn’t think it was necessary to take the case before a grand jury, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

He said that whatever may have led up to the skirmish, Scurlock pouncing on Gardner from behind was what led Gardner to fire his weapon to protect himself.

Kleine, a Democrat elected to office four times, condemned people – including a local Democratic congressional candidate – for distorting the facts of the case on social media, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Authorities have disputed online accounts that David Gardner also had a gun and that Jake Gardner used racial slurs the night he was attacked by Scurlock.

Police said a member of Scurlock’s group told investigators he hadn’t heard anyone use racial slurs during the altercation, the Omaha World-Herald reported.

Protesters were already gathered in Omaha when the district attorney made the announcement that Jake Gardner would not be charged.

After Kleine explained his decision, hundreds more protesters headed downtown to join the demonstration.

Comments are closed.